Why Your Airbnb Isn’t Getting Rebooked (Even with 5-Star Reviews)
Most Airbnb hosts assume that five-star reviews automatically lead to repeat bookings. That’s not how it works. If you’re constantly chasing new guests and watching platform fees eat into your profits, it’s time to break the cycle. There’s a smarter way to fill your calendar without relying on Airbnb to do it for you.
This guide will show you:
- Why most guests never return… even when they loved their stay
- The real reason your Airbnb isn’t getting rebooked
- Step-by-step strategies to turn first-time guests into regulars
- How to build a brand that people remember and trust
Follow these steps and you’ll see a measurable ROI. No skipping ;)
CE
by Candice Eugene
The Harsh Truth About Repeat Bookings
Here’s a stat every host must know:
Over 80% of Airbnb guests NEVER rebook the same property—even if they left a glowing review. Why? Because Airbnb’s design keeps them loyal to the platform, not to you.
When guests think of where to stay, they think “Airbnb,” not “that amazing loft hosted by Sarah in Nashville.” That’s a branding gap. And if you’re not building contact with past guests, you’re invisible the next time they book a trip.
Here’s what most hosts get wrong:
- They expect reviews to drive loyalty.
- They never collect guest emails or contacts.
- They have no brand presence outside Airbnb.
- They never follow up post-stay.
If you’re not building and owning relationships with guests, you’re running on a treadmill of finding new ones.
Look at Robuilt. He leveraged YouTube and social media to transform from anonymous host to STR industry giant. Now, he doesn’t just get bookings. He attracts repeat guests, investors, and fans. He built a reliable brand.
You don’t need 100,000 YouTube subscribers. But you MUST apply the same principles if you want your Airbnb business to last.
The hosts who scale aren’t just renting rooms.
They’re building brands that guests remember, return to, and recommend.
Let's break down the five biggest reasons guests don’t return to your Airbnb, even when they had a great experience.
1. Relying 100% on Airbnb Means Nobody Remembers YOU
Here’s the truth: Airbnb is engineered so guests remember the platform, not the host. That means if they look for another place in your city next year, your amazing house just disappears into a sea of listings.
Solution: Get Attention on Social Media
Don’t wait for Airbnb to put you in the spotlight. Claim your own space online.
Action Steps:
- Post regular content about your property and guest experiences on Instagram, TikTok, YouTube Shorts, and Pinterest.
- Showcase your space, highlight guest stories, and share local recommendations.
- Use trending formats and sounds to boost reach.
If you host a romantic getaway, your content should appeal to couples—not solo travelers or business people.
Match your content to your ideal guest.
Example: “POV: You just checked into the perfect Nashville honeymoon Airbnb…” With this approach, someone planning a romantic trip will think of you first.
Why This Works
1
Visibility = Bookings.
If guests can’t find you, they can’t return.
2
Trust grows with familiarity.
Seeing your brand repeatedly builds confidence.
3
People book from people they trust.
The more they see you, the more they trust you. They won’t book if they don’t trust you.
So how do you make sure guests remember YOU, and not just Airbnb?
By building a personal brand and making sure they see you everywhere.
Tip: Use trending sounds and formats to make your content discoverable.
One strategy you can leverage is using trends and tied it with your brand or properties. That is the simplest and easiest way you can grab attention nowadays.
Example: Instead of just showing a walkthrough of your Airbnb, make it engaging
→ “POV: You just checked into the best Airbnb in [your city]”—then show the highlights of your stay.
- Look at what’s trending on Instagram & TikTok.
- Find a way to tie it into your STR property.
- Use trending audio with captions like “This is your sign to book a cozy getaway.”
Why does this work? Because trends capture attention FAST.
2. You’re Not Moving Guests from Social Media to Direct Booking
You might get eyes on your content, but unless you give viewers an easy path to booking, you’ll lose them to another listing.
Solution: Funnel Attention to Value and Trust
Leverage short-form content to capture attention. Then, nurture leads with long-form content that warms them up to your brand.
Action Steps:
- Link from your shorts or reels to YouTube videos or a blog.
- Publish blogs & guides about things to do in your location, travel tips, and what makes your Airbnb stand out.
- Offer something free (like a local travel guide) in exchange for a visitor’s email.
Example Funnel:
1
TikTok video shows off your property (“Best Weekend Getaway in Charleston!”)
2
Caption links to your YouTube guide (“Full itinerary & insider tips!”)
3
YouTube points viewers to your site for a discount or freebie.
4
Website collects emails and gives the guide in return.
When guests read your guides and watch your videos, your brand becomes their “go-to.”
The process itself is quite simple, but it requires dedication—and that’s precisely why many property owners haven’t taken advantage of it yet. It’s time-consuming, challenging, and demands commitment.
However, this presents a great opportunity for you. By embracing this strategy, you can gain a competitive edge, stand out in the market, and attract more guests.
While others hesitate, you’ll be building visibility and trust, positioning your business as the clear choice for guests.
3. You’re Not Using Winning Content as Ads
Most hosts waste money on random ads and posts. They see zero results because they’re not doubling down on what works.
Solution: Turn Top-Performing Content Into Paid Ads
Look for the TikTok, reel, or pin that gets the best engagement. Amplify it with paid promotions or use it as a retargeting ad. Direct these viewers straight into your booking funnel.
Action Steps:
- Identify which piece of content performs best. Take your best-performing Instagram/TikTok video and turn it into a paid ad.
- Run ads targeting your ideal audience (people interested in travel to your city, for example).
- Always link the ad to your long-form content or booking page—not to your Airbnb listing.
Why This Works: Ads built on real, proven content outperform random or “salesy” ads every time. You’re meeting people where they already show interest.
If you just throw ads out there for your direct booking website to people who don’t know you, they won’t have a reason to book with you. In today’s world, just showing off your great designs and reviews isn’t enough. You really need to capture their interest in a different way, because simply promoting direct bookings won’t turn strangers into customers for your property.
4. You’re Not Collecting or Following Up with Guest Contacts
Once you’ve captured their attention on social media, it’s time to give guests a way to book directly with you, outside of Airbnb.
To build a lasting brand, you need to position your property as more than just another Airbnb listing. If guests only associate your place with Airbnb, retaining them becomes much harder.
Why does this matter?
Even if a past guest wants to stay again, they might struggle to find you if they’re searching exclusively on Airbnb—and could end up booking elsewhere.
By creating a direct booking website (DBW), you strengthen your brand, showcase your unique values, and stand out from the sea of generic Airbnb listings. Guests shouldn’t see your property as just another Airbnb; they should recognize it as your brand—a memorable, one-of-a-kind experience.
Here’s the hard truth: If you don’t make it easy for past guests to book directly with you, they’ll turn to a host who does.
People are busy. With countless distractions competing for their attention, even guests who loved their stay might forget about you—unless you stay top of mind.
This is why collecting guest emails is so important. With their contact information, you can nurture the relationship and remind them to book directly with you in the future.
Solution: Collect and Nurture Guest Contacts.
Build a direct booking website, capture emails, and create a seamless experience that keeps guests coming back. Don’t leave your repeat business to chance—make it effortless for them to choose you again.
Action Steps:
1
Step 1: Use a STR Booking Platform
Platforms like Lodgify, Hostfully, or Uplisting let you create a professional, easy-to-book website that isn’t controlled by Airbnb.
2
Step 2: Create a Reason for Guests to Book Direct
You need to give them a reason to book beyond just asking them to book away from airbnb.
Offer exclusive incentives such as the free guides that i showed you before, but you can also do something like a
- Discounted rates for repeat guests.
- Bonus perks—free breakfast, extended checkout, local guidebooks.
- Loyalty program—after 3 stays, get a free night.
3
Step 3: Incentivize guests to share their email
Create a sign up form, offering your exclusive incentives (discount on next stay, local guide, secret perks, etc.)
4
Step 4: Send a welcome email after checkout
With a personal note and a special offer for booking direct next time.
5
Step 5: Create a monthly or seasonal newsletter
With local events, property upgrades, or loyalty discounts.
The inbox is often where travel decisions are made. A single email can mean another $1,000+ booking next year.
5. Zero Personal Branding = Zero Guest Loyalty
If your guests only remember “Nice condo, nice stay,” you lose to anyone who runs a promotion or slashes prices next time. Personal connection wins loyalty.
Solution: Build a Brand Presence Your Guests Will Remember
Action Steps:
- Develop a unique style or story around your Airbnb (eco-friendly, family-run, design-forward).
- Share photos and videos of yourself preparing the space, sharing local secrets, or even just saying thank you to guests.
- Showcase repeat guest testimonials and “returning stories” on social media.
Why This Works: People book with brands, not just properties. Rebookings aren’t driven by amenities; they’re driven by memorable host experiences.
Putting It All Together for Consistent Bookings (and a Strong ROI)
Here’s the bottom line:
If you want more repeat bookings, you need to stop playing by Airbnb’s rules and start building your own guest loyalty engine. Every skipped step is a booking (and income) lost.
Summary Checklist:
- Don’t rely on Airbnb for guest retention
- Get visible across social channels with targeted, memorable content
- Funnel that attention to value-driven blogs, guides, or YouTube content
- Turn high-performing content into ads with a clear path to your booking site
- Collect, nurture, and follow up with guest contacts for future stays
- Invest in building a brand—not just a listing
You don’t need to become a YouTube star.
But you MUST become the “go-to” property that guests remember, share, and book again.
Do all these steps, and expect a real boost in direct bookings, repeat stays, and ultimately, your ROI.
No more chasing new guests every week.
Take Charge of Your Airbnb’s Future
Success on Airbnb isn’t about earning five-star reviews and hoping for the best. It’s about taking active steps to win guests’ hearts, wallets, and loyalty. Start building your brand and system now, and you’ll own your calendar—not just fill it.
Next steps:
- Pick one platform (Instagram, TikTok, Pinterest) and start posting daily about your property and guest stories.
- Set up a simple direct booking website with a way to collect emails.
- Test sharing a freebie (guide, discount, secret local tip) in exchange for that contact.
- Watch which content performs best, then double down and turn it into an ad.
Building a rebooking system isn’t optional if you want to stand out and scale up.
Start today, and make every guest a regular.
Want our help to implement all of this?
Book a strategy call with us today, we’ll help you identify your revenue and time leakages, and create a customized plan to fix them.
Don’t leave growth to chance… take the first step toward scaling your business with confidence!
I help short-term rental businesses unlock 5–10% more revenue and occupancy in under 60 days,
While also saving you overhead cost and 20+ hours a month by automating the backend of your business.
www.scalehavenly.com